2020
Tournament Cancelled due to Covid concerns
2019
| Place | Team | Location | Record |
| 1st | Vincennes University (4th – 1965, 1970, 1972) | Vincennes, IN | 33-2 |
| 2nd | Ranger College | Ranger, TX | 31-4 |
Third place game eliminated following the 2018 tournament
2018
| Place | Team | Location | Record |
| 1st | South Plains College (3rd – 2008, 2012) | Levelland, TX | 29-8 |
| 2nd | College of Southern Idaho | Twin Falls, ID | 30-6 |
| 3rd | Eastern Florida State College | Melbourne, FL | 30-5 |
| 4th | Vincennes University | Vincennes, IN | 34-3 |
2017
| Place | Team | Location | Record |
| 1st | Hutchinson CC (3rd – 1988, 1994) | Hutchinson, KS | 35-2 |
| 2nd | Eastern Florida State College | Melbourne, FL | 31-6 |
| 3rd | South Plains College | Levelland, TX | 32-2 |
| 4th | Northwest Florida State College | Niceville, FL | 29-5 |
2016
| Place | Team | Location | Record |
| 1st | Salt Lake CC (2nd Championship – 2009) | Taylorsville, UT | 31-8 |
| 2nd | Hutchinson CC | Hutchinson, KS | 32-5 |
| 3rd | Gillette College | Gillette, WY | 35-2 |
| 4th | Ranger College | Ranger, TX | 31-7 |
2015
| Place | Team | Location | Record |
| 1st | Northwest Florida State College (Second – 1995) | Niceville, FL | 33-2 |
| 2nd | South Plains College | Levelland, TX | 29-7 |
| 3rd | Hill College | Hillsboro, TX | 32-4 |
| 4th | Georgia Highlands College | Rome, GA | 30-8 |
2014
| Place | Team | Location | Record |
| 1st | Jones College | Ellisville, MS | 28-5 |
| 2nd | Indian Hills CC | Ottumwa, IA | 34-3 |
| 3rd | Vincennes University | Vincennes, IN | 34-3 |
| 4th | Harcum College | Bryn Mawr, PA | 32-5 |
2013
| Place | Team | Location | Record |
| 1st | College of Central Florida | Ocala, FL | 34-3 |
| 2nd | Northwest Florida State College | Niceville, FL | 30-4 |
| 3rd | Spartanburg Methodist College | Spartanburg, SC | 35-1 |
| 4th | Vincennes University | Vincennes, IN | 33-4 |
Format went to single elimination doing away with the 5th and 7th Place Games
2012
| Place | Team | Location | Record |
| 1st | South Plains College (2nd – 2008) | Levelland, TX | 36-0 |
| 2nd | Northwest Florida State College | Niceville, FL | 31-2 |
| 3rd | Seward Co. CC | Liberal, KS | 31-6 |
| 4th | Eastern Oklahoma State College | Wilburton, OK | 32-5 |
| 5th | Monroe College | New Rochelle, NY | 33-4 |
| 6th | Columbia State CC | Columbia, TN | 23-8 |
| 7th | Indian Hills CC | Ottumwa, IA | 33-4 |
| 8th | Wabash Valley College | Mount Carmel, IL | 27-10 |
2011
| Place | Team | Location | Record |
| 1st | College of Southern Idaho (3rd – 1976, 1987) | Twin Falls, ID | 33-4 |
| 2nd | Midland College | Midland, TX | 33-4 |
| 3rd | Monroe College | New Rochelle, NY | 31-5 |
| 4th | Southeastern CC | W. Burlington, IA | 29-8 |
| 5th | Coffeyville CC | Coffeyville, KS | 33-5 |
| 6th | Shelton State CC | Tuscaloosa, AL | 28-9 |
| 7th | Western Wyoming CC | Rock Springs, WY | 28-10 |
| 8th | Cape Fear CC | Wilmington, NC | 29-9 |
